(Photo courtesy Brothers To The Rescue)
It’s time for our annual remembrance of the anniversary of one of the truly dark days in American history. On February 24, 1996 three U.S. citizens and one legal U.S. resident were flying a humanitarian mission over the Straits of Florida. They and another pilot were flying three small private planes looking for refugees in the shark infested waters between Cuba and the United States. fidel and raul castro ordered them murdered, and a pilot in the Cuban Air Force, flying a jet fighter, shot down two of the three planes. The Clinton Administration did nothing in response.
Armando Alejandre, Mario de la Pina, Carlos Costa and Pablo Morales were flying a humanitarian mission for Brothers To The Rescue (Hermanos Al Rescate) that day. The men were flying two small, civilian planes when Cuban MiGs, under the direct orders of fidel casto blew them out of the sky. A third plane, piloted by Jose Basulto, escaped.I have to rely on memory for the events leading up to their deaths. The World Wide Web was still new in the early 90s, and a lot of the background doesn’t seem to be online. But here’s what had happened, to the best of my recollection.
The fall of the Soviet Union in 1991 deprived fidel of economic support. Cuba was undergoing such a financial crisis, horses were once again in the streets of Havana and oxen were working the farms in place of tractors. Brothers to the Rescue was formed at that time – from the group’s website
Brothers to the Rescue was founded in May 1991 after several pilots were touched by the death of a fifteen year old adolescent named Gregorio Pérez Ricardo, who fleeing Castro’s Cuba on a raft, perished of severe dehydration. The organization, a small, non-profit corporation, conducts its humanitarian missions searching for rafters in the Florida Straits, through the efforts of a group of pilots, observers and volunteers from numerous countries, including Argentina, Cuba, Perú, France, Jamaica, Nicaragua, Puerto Rico, Switzerland, the United States, Venezuela and former Cuban rafters.
Brothers to the Rescue has conducted over 2,400 aerial search missions. These operations have resulted in the rescue of more than 4,200 men, women and children ranging from a five day old infant to a man 79 years of age, and the rescue of thousands of others during the refugee crisis of 1994.
The refugee crisis of 1994 began with food riots in Havana. I was working for a Fox television station at the time (this was before the Fox News Channel existed) and Fox fed a little video of the ruckus. Cubans began again to make concentrated efforts to escape fidel’s gulag.
On July 13, 1994, an old tugboat “13 de Marzo” carried 72 people as they tried to escape Cuba. As later found by The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, four Cuban patrol boats attacked the tug seven miles off the coast. The Cuban boats first fired water cannon, then rammed the boat and sank it. 41-people died – many of them children 31-people survived to write their stories of that awful day.
The three Polargo tug boats surrounded our ship and began using the high pressure water hoses once again forcing “13 de Marzo” to get away from the coast. They crashed “13 de Marzo” intentionally again and over again, trying to overturn us. But “13 de Marzo”‘s structure was really strong. Then they decided to stand one in front and one behind us. The Polargo behind us hit “13 de Marzo” several times until our tug boat began to sink. When they saw our ship was sinking, the Polargo behind us rode 13 de Marzo’s stern. Fifty percent of “13 de Marzo” was already under water at that time.
About 30 people remained trapped into “13 de Marzo”‘s holds. Those of us who could reach the water surface saw how the Polargos were making whirlpools around us at a high speed. They remained doing this for over 40 minutes. Obviously, they were trying not to leave survivors who could become dangerous witnesses. A group of 15 to 18, including my son Sergio and I, grabbed a floating ice box. So we could survive. We knew nothing about other members of our family also on “13 de Marzo”.
Through the late summer and fall, the turmoil on the island continued, and people began to escape on the most fragile of rafts. The beaches of Florida, even as far north as St. Augustine, were littered with the remains. Many were simply pieces of wood holding together thick pieces of Styrofoam, glued together with a black, tar-like substance, and attached to huge air-filled inner tubes that were branded Made In China. How did these people have the courage to brave the sea in those frail craft? It must show the value of freedom.
Brothers to the Rescue helped los balseros (the rafters) greatly in 1994. As they say on their site, they selflessly flew missions over the Florida Straits, spotted the refugees and radioed their location to U.S. Coast Guard vessels, which, at the time, actually rescued the people and carried them to safety in the United States. This was before the days of Wet Foot-Dry Foot.
The exile community was enraged over the 13 de Marzo incident. Movimiento Democricia (Democracy Movement) conducted a memorial service for the victims on the first anniversary of the massacre, July 13, 1995. The Movement wanted to call attention to the plight of the Cuban people through peaceful protest, and organized a flotilla of boats that sailed as close as they could to the site of the killings while remaining in International waters. Los Hermanos flew air cover over the flotilla.
Brothers to the Rescue pilots continued to fly air missions through late 1995 and into early 1996. On February 17, 1996, the doomed pilots flew a humanitarian mission to the Bahamas to give food to refugees there (photo courtesy Brothers to the Rescue).
On February 24, 1996, the four men plus Basulto flew their three unarmed aircraft over the straits. That’s when fidel decided to strike. He told Dan Rather in a 1996 interview that he personally took responsibility for ordering the attack.
The MiGs were under direct orders from Cuban dictator Fidel Castro, who told CBS News’ Dan Rather in a Sept. 3, 1996, interview, “In fact they had the authority to do it, and I assume the responsibility.”
A Cuban MiG shot the four men out of the sky over International waters. Brothers to the Rescue has a recording of the MiG’s radio transmissions during the attack.
A week after the murders, exiles held another memorial service, this one in the air.
Eighteen small civilian planes lifted into a wet, gray sky Saturday afternoon as hundreds of supporters at Opa-locka airport cheered, honked their horns, waved flags and flashed their car lights.
Destination: the Florida Straits, where four Brothers to the Rescue flyers were gunned down by Cuban MiGs a week earlier.
The funeral flight ended about 17 miles north of Cuba, where pilots — from the Brothers group, Rafters Rescue Legion and the Cuban-American Pilots Association — circled in what they call a “racetrack formation” for about half an hour.
Father Francisco Santana of Ermita De La Caridad Catholic Church, flying in the lead plane piloted by Brothers founder Jose Basulto, said a eulogy while one by one, pilots and their passengers tossed flowers into the sea.
Mourners attended a memorial service at the Orange Bowl in Miami. Val Prieto remembers:
I was there with my girlfriend at the time, a Colombian girl who despite having lived her whole life in Miami had never really delved into the Cuban psyche of its diaspora. She was there with me for me. She knew what it meant to me. I had to be there. I had to go regardless of the hurt. She’d seen me crying for days. Seen my father depressed and my mother somber. She’d seen the anger build up in me and turn into a rage, then, as quickly as it had begun, lulled into a whimpering sob.
There were thousands of people there. I remember I had to fight back tears the moment we made it through the ramp and up into the stands. So many people, I thought. So many flags.
As he prepared to leave office, President Clinton gave an interview to Dan Rather. On December 18, 2000, Mr. Clinton expressed his outrage:
THE PRESIDENT: Yes. They shot those Brothers To The Rescue planes down, in blatant violation of international law. We don’t believe they were in Cuban territorial waters. But even if they were in Cuban territorial waters, it was illegal. Cuba is a signatory to the Chicago Convention which specifically says how you have to handle planes like that. It governs what we do when we see planes take off from South America, small planes that we know are unarmed that may have drugs on them. A lot of times we have to follow them until they go down somewhere, or do that.
What they did, it was a deliberate illegal killing.
fidel casto’s legacy – deliberate, illegal killing.
North Carolina Senator Jesse Helms expressed the outrage that many Americans felt.
There were new developments in 2008. First, the movie Shootdown played in limited theaters across the country. Watch the trailer here:
Also in 2008, now that fidel has stepped down and is no longer a head of state, Congresswoman Ileana Ros-Lehtinen says it’s time to indict fidel for murder. From the Kansas City Star
But Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, R-Miami, is calling for him to be indicted for the 1996 shootdown of two Brothers to the Rescue aircraft — saying he has “formally stepped down as head of state.”
”It matters nothing at all whether Fidel, Raúl or any other thug is named head of anything in Cuba,” Ros-Lehtinen said. “What the people want is freedom to express their dissent from the oppressive regime. The community machinery is enslaving them so it does not matter who the thug of the moment will be.”
She suggested Castro’s resignation, however, ”clears the path for immediate legal action” and called for U.S. authorities to indict Castro for the shootdown.
”This is but the first step in bringing Fidel and other Cuban war criminals to justice,” she said.
Bring war criminals to justice, indeed.
Update – Our friend Alberto Quiroga remembers his classmate, Armando Alejandre.
And in 2009, we have a new book about the murders. Here’s the publisher’s blurb:
BETRAYAL: Clinton, Castro & the Cuban Five
On February 24, 1996, two U.S. civilian aircraft flying a rescue mission in international airspace off Cuba were shot down by Cuban Air Force MiG fighters. Four Americans, including three U.S. citizens, lost their lives. In a new, explosive book titled, BETRAYAL, co-authors Thomas Van Hare (former member of the CPA) and Matt Lawrence recount how back door politics, failed negotiations and NORAD’s inaction allowed Cuba to murder American citizens. The cover up that followed went from Havana to the halls of the Clinton White House.
After thirteen years of exhaustive research and two years of writing, BETRAYAL reveals:
- The aircraft shot down were never in Cuban airspace and the shootdown was planned and practiced in advance, closely monitored by U.S. radars, on direct order from Washington.
- The U.S. Government was deeply penetrated by Cuban spies who manipulated public opinion and controlled U.S. policy to Fidel Castro’s ends.
- USAF F-15 fighters could have intervened, but did not, even as Cuban MiGs chased an aircraft nearly to Key West.
- Documents released by the U.S. Government reveal prior knowledge by senior Clinton Administration officials, including Sandy Berger, Gov. Bill Richardson, and top advisor, Richard Nuccio.
- Cuban spies now in jail, including the Cuban Five, were involved in the shootdown; they are the central focus of Cuba’s latest round of diplomacy with the Obama Administration.
- The case of the Cuban Five, including convictions for conspiracy to commit murder and aiding and abetting, is currently being sent before the U.S. Supreme Court – even while Cuban Government officials plead to the Obama Administration for their release.
Buy the Book Today:
Visit the Website – and HEAR the shootdown (turn on your speakers):
Please help us shed light on a truth long buried – and an issue that is timely for America today.